Should You Replace Or Repair Your Garage Door Opener?
Garage Door Opener Repair

Is it Time to Repair or Replace Your Garage Door Opener?

The answer to this question is very different now than it was a year or two ago prior to COVID. The issues with the supply chain, lack of workforce, shortages, price increases, and shipping costs combined with inflation have impacted how I’m going to advise you. It’s January 2022 and there have been a ton of changes in the garage door opener world. 

Garage door openers are built to last 8-15 years on average. There are many reasons why you may need garage door opener repair prior to that. I’m going to cover a few of them below. 

Common Garage Door Opener Problems

Garage Door Opener Won’t Open

This is a common garage door opener repair. However, in some cases when your garage door won’t open, it’s not the garage door opener at all. Sometimes the issue is with the garage door springs that assist with opening the door. Garage door springs are your counterbalance. The opener is designed to guide the garage door through the tracks. If the springs aren’t broken, the next obvious thing to diagnose is the weight of the door. The springs may not be broken but they could have relaxed prior to breaking that would cause the door to be too heavy for the opener to lift. 

It’s important that you invest in a spring replacement or you could soon be replacing the garage door opener too. A heavy door will damage your garage door opener and require a fix. A simple fix is to confirm your remotes have good batteries. If the batteries are good and the door balances properly, consider the possibility of the circuit board or some sort of radio interference. A few other simple fixes are to check for a GFI outlet in the garage that could have tripped or the carriage carrier is disengaged. If all of that isn’t the issue, the last thing could be a stripped gear inside the housing. You can remove a few screws and if you peek into the housing of the garage door opener, you may see shavings from the nylon gear.

Garage Door Opener Won’t Close

Some of the same things apply from above, but the primary reasons a garage door won’t close is a loose cable or the safety sensors on your garage door opener are not powered on or something is tripping them. Check out our article about garage door sensors

Garage Door Opens Randomly By Itself

This is commonly known as “ghost opening” when your garage door opener randomly opens or closes your garage door. It’s probably not as random as you may think. In most cases, it’s picking up a frequency from a neighbor’s remote. This is pretty common when a garage door opener has a bad circuit board. In some cases, if a specific part of the board is damaged, it can cause this. It’s definitely a security issue and we suggest replacing your garage door opener unless it’s under 5 years old. 

So when do you replace your garage door opener vs fixing it? 

This is up to you and can be determined by budget and your plans with the home. My garage door company, Aaron Overhead Doors, tries to treat every situation differently. If the homeowner plans to sell the home within a month or two, it may make more sense to fix it. Some homeowners feel it’s important and don’t want to risk garage door opener issues during inspection. It’s extremely difficult to diagnose an opener that isn’t working. A repair may just reveal more issues after it’s working. If you plan to stay in the home for a while and the opener is over 5 years old, it may be a great time to replace it. The quality of the existing opener should also be taken into consideration. A lot of homeowners have a builder-grade opener that may be loud or not built to last. All of these things can be considered with a great Q&A conversation. 

See our article on “How long do garage door openers last?”

If you need garage door opener repair and you’re in the metro Atlanta area, consider my company Aaron Overhead Doors!

Shane Riza profile pictureShane Riza
14:58 12 Sep 25
Excellent responsiveness. There was a question on where to put the window panel and Matt was committed to getting it right even if it meant redoing some work. Great work and very efficient. Will definitely use this company again.
Bruce Coppedge profile pictureBruce Coppedge
13:58 10 Sep 25
Aaron’s tech Joe arrived on time and completed the installation in a timely manner. He’s very professional and personable. I’ll definitely call Aaron w/ any future garage door issues.
John Thornhill profile pictureJohn Thornhill
16:17 02 Sep 25
Joe was great, super helpful and very informative.

will be sure to use these guys for all garage related issues in the future!
Bob Stiller profile pictureBob Stiller
17:15 28 Aug 25
The entire company was fantastic- from Bree calling me back on Memorial day to Joe arriving Tuesday morning to address my issue. The entire door system was reviewed nd evaluated thoroughly.
Joe patiently explained what I had, needed to be done and what my options in general were for repair. Once the estimate was ready, Joe again patiently explained the repair options and discussed in detail any specific line items I either didn't understand or was looking for clarification on.
The estimates were fair and reasonable for the work involved and once I made my choice the work was begun and finished well within the time frame Don gave me for the repair. I am extremely pleased with everything- top to bottom and will continue to highly recommend Aaron Overhead Doors to anyone looking for garage door repairs/ replacement.
Fabio Penta profile pictureFabio Penta
19:01 25 Aug 25
I highly recommend Aaron Overhead Doors for any garage door needs. Joe Simon is professional, knowledgeable, and truly values his customers. Ally, who manages the service calls, is also extremely friendly and helpful.

When my garage door motor stopped working after just two years, Joe and the team took care of everything from start to finish with LiftMaster. They were completely honest, immediately let me know the unit was still under warranty, and kept me informed every step of the way while arranging the replacement. The entire process was seamless and stress-free thanks to their expertise and integrity.
Mike Thomason profile pictureMike Thomason
18:00 25 Aug 25
Highly recommend Aaron Overhead Doors of Buford. They installed a garage door about 4 years ago. Called just for service and safety check - no issues. Largest item in the house, so wanted to be sure. Joe was very pleasant and helpful with answering all questions. The safety check and regular maintenance was completed quickly.
Julie Schoen profile pictureJulie Schoen
14:52 25 Aug 25
Heidi Stephens profile pictureHeidi Stephens
13:48 20 Aug 25
Our sales person was wonderful - he really went the extra mile to find out what we needed and wanted. And the installation team was great - they were attentive and made doubly sure that everything was safely installed and that we were happy with the final results. It's been five months since the garage doors were installed, and we love them. We will certainly use Aaron Overhead Doors if we need garage door services in the future, and we are happy to refer them to others who need new doors or garage door service.
Jon Christopher profile pictureJon Christopher
22:14 13 Aug 25
Matt was very attentive when I ask questions and he is very knowledgeable about the garage doors .
He made me feel comfortable

Over 3,000 5 ★★★★★ STAR Reviews

AOD Logo
Map of Aaron Overhead Doors Locations
Scroll to Top